Hi June and welcome. This sounds like an issue with your specific firearm. Different magazines and ammo points to the pistol. I would contact Beretta Customer Service for a solution/service at 1.800.Beretta (237-3882). Cheers and stay safe!

Time to contact Beretta Customer Service 1.800.Beretta (237-3882)

Sorry to hear this. I had a jamming/feeding issue with my Berretta 950 Jetfire years ago. In my case It was a magazine issue. New Mecgar mags resolved my issue. Since you've ruled out mags by swapping them into your BF's Tomcat I'd also give Berrettas customer service a call.
CONTACT US
At Beretta, we strive to provide you with exceptional customer service. Whether you need to service your firearm or check the status of an order, you can find all the information you need by clicking one of the links below or by contacting our dedicated service team at 1.800. Beretta (237-3882).