BudsGunShop.com - Holster fit

Hi Nick and welcome. Yes, a Smith & Wesson Shield Plus will generally fit in standard Shield holsters as the two models are very similar in size, with the main difference being the increased magazine capacity in the Shield Plus; meaning most holsters designed for the original Shield will also accommodate the Shield Plus.

Hi Nick, I would opt for a dedicated Shield Plus holster. Smith & Wesson has advertised that the Shield Plus would fit regular Shield holsters, but unfortunately they changed some critical dimensions, so the fit and retention are very poor.
Stay safe & have a great day!