My vote and opinion would be the Stoeger Longfowler O/U between the two Aaron. I may be a little biased, but it is what it is my man.

They will both be ok at sporting but you neither will have a long life if you really get into target shooting you can do better with a good used Remington 1100 with screwing chokes I shoot 15,000 + targets a year between skeet and sporting and there is a reason that you still see a lot of Remington 1100s in the 12 gauge events you will never see a hatfield at a stoeger in a completion