Anthony - You ask for opinions, but didn't specify what your intended use is for the revolver. If you are going to carry daily, then the Taurus is the obvious choice, due to size and weight. If you want something to just shoot occasionally at the range, then the EAA is more what you're looking for. If you're looking for something to do both, then I would say the Taurus is the way to go, and then shoot 38s in it at the range. You could carry it with 357s ... but shoot a few first so the recoil doesn't totally surprise you the first time you shoot it. Shooting .357 in a revolver as light and small as the Taurus is going to be torture after a few rounds. The EAA could help handle the extra recoil. Bottom line is .. what you intend to use the firearm for.

Anthony, I actually have both. The Taurus is what I use for carry as the EAA Windicator is larger than one would think. It will give you an extra round over the Taurus but there will be a trade-off in carry comfort for sure. The Windicator is hefty but built like a tank.

I have the 605 and have shot the EAA. The EAA is heavier and seems to be built stronger. The 605 is almost impossible to hold onto when shooting .357 and after about ten rounds you're going to notice it.