Joey, you must send Bud's a copy of your FID card. It's quite simple, I have bought plenty of ammo from Bud's, I'm in NJ too. You can upload it here budsgunshop.com/contact_us.php?printForm=ammocredentials&state=New%20Jersey

Joey, Handgun Ammunition Qualifier: Handgun ammunition is defined by NJ Law as ammunition specifically designed to be used only in a handgun. For purchase of handgun ammunition,the purchaser must present a valid firearms purchasers identification card, a valid permit to purchase a handgun, or a valid permit to carry a handgun. Details under Ammunition/Accessories here : budsgunshop.com/feeds/state_reg/new_jersey_restrictions.pdf (email or fax to FFL@BudsGunShop.com or
Fax : 1-800-804-5569)