Hi Jason and welcome. Surprisingly, the quality is equal. Whichever one you can get for the best deal is the deciding factor in this case. Cheers and stay safe!

Jason, this is a big online debate Wich ones better. Does seem from people who have owned both tend to say the cimarron has better fit and finish and slightly better trigger. They're both made by uberti like you said so I can't see there being much of a difference if any. Either way both are fine revolvers. Hope this helps some and good luck with your choice.